Not sold on Melo or K-Love as HoF locks. Melo scored a lot of points but he underachieved in terms of team success and his game has fallen badly in recent times. Kevin Love was a big stats no wins player in Minnesota and then declined badly in Cleveland as 3rd/4th best player on team.
Pau Gasol should be moved up to 100% tier. Led Memphis to playoffs, 2nd best player on two title winning teams and a Finals loser. Huge accomplishments with Spanish National team. Aged reasonably well in Chicago and San Antonio.
What? Melo may have been underwhelming in his success for post-season, but he's most assuredly going to end up in the HoF. Denver Melo was a problem. And Kevin Love?
I mean look at both of their resumes...
Love
NBA champion (2016)
5× NBA All-Star (2011, 2012, 2014, 2017, 2018)
2× All-NBA Second Team (2012, 2014)
NBA Most Improved Player (2011)
NBA All-Rookie Second Team (2009)
NBA Three-Point Shootout champion (2012)
NBA rebounding leader (2011)
Consensus first-team All-American (2008)
Pac-10 Player of the Year (2008)
First-team All-Pac-10 (2008)
Naismith Prep Player of the Year (2007)
Carmelo
10× NBA All-Star (2007, 2008, 2010–2017)
2× All-NBA Second Team (2010, 2013)
4× All-NBA Third Team (2006, 2007, 2009, 2012)
NBA scoring champion (2013)
NBA All-Rookie First Team (2004)
NBA Rookie Challenge MVP (2005)
NCAA champion (2003)
NCAA Final Four Most Outstanding Player (2003)
Consensus second-team All-American (2003)
USBWA National Freshman of the Year (2003)
No. 15 retired by Syracuse
3× USA Basketball Male Athlete of the Year (2006, 2008, 2016)
Melo is 98.2% HoF probability on Basketball-reference, and even though he's been a ball hog. He's been one of the deadliest scorers, won in college basketball, and been a scoring champion. All second/third teams definitely boost that percentage.
Love? He's very close to be honest. He just needs to nail 2-3 more Allstars. (Which I can see happening if the Pacers or another East team tries to trade for him, and he plays in the weak East, as it's easy to make it into Allstar.) Maybe secure 1 or 2 more All NBA teams, but he's pretty close. He's the quintessential stretch 4 in today's NBA, whether or not you wanna discredit his lack of defense as a key selling point for why he shouldn't make it.