Simmons is 4 wins away from joining that list. Mitchell got awfully close, but the Jazz can't quite hit 50 wins.
How is Simmons four wins from joining that group? He’s way older than Tatum.
Did you not read the opening post in the thread?
"There are only 4 other rookies that have done this are Kareem, Bird, Robinson, and Duncan."
Simmons is now 3 wins away from joining that list.
What you say is true, but Simmons is a redshirt rookie. What he has achieved just underlines how talented a player he is but I don't put his achievements on the exact same playing field as Tatum because Simmons had an extra year to get his body ready for the NBA while he sat out his first season.
Tatum's second season in the NBA compared to Simmon's 'rookie' year would be a more fair comparison. I believe Tatum will turn out to be a great player. I'm just hoping we can hold onto him even if we make a big trade aka Leonard or Davis.
This redshirt argument is weak. In college football, redshirted players are part of the team. They spend the season practicing with the team, learning the playbook, etc. They get coached like other players. In some cases due to injury, they end up playing and lose their redshirt season.
Simmons was recovering from foot surgery for most of that redshirt year. He wasn't part of the team. The coaches were focused on the season and the active players on the team not on Simmons' development. Coach Brown didn't start coaching Simmons about the PG role until the offseason. Playing actual NBA games is much more beneficial than sitting out.