For the record, I will go ahead and define "star". If we set an over-under of 2 all-star appearances, I am going to take the under. Like I said, I'm not trying to kill the guy because I think he can be a good player on a good team. Maybe a third best player on a good team.
I just don't see a multiple all-star due to some glaring weaknesses related to his handle (which is still basic and loose) and his feel for the game.