Are people nuts? I live Tatum but there are quite a few players I would trade for and gladly include him aline or part of a package. KP, Giannis, AD, Towns, Jokic to name a few. This "Would you trade him straight up for AD" question is absurd. Of course you do that! That makes him tradeable. Nobody on this year except maaaybe kyrie is untradeable.
I'm not sure why so many people are in such a hurry to trade integral parts of a team on pace for 70 wins (WITHOUT Hayward). My only explanation is the the grass is always greener or some such ****. Jokic?? Seriously? And I want no part of Giannis after his recent explosion.
Jokic is a star. If you think him vs. tatum is obvious then you likely havent been paying attention to the Nuggets.
You have a low threshold for 'star' then. But, as usual, there are at least 50 'top 5' guys in the league.
It's common for many people to talk about stars and superstars and separate tiers. A perennial MVP candidate is a superstar. An All-Star is a star.
Currently, I'd say there are 7 superstars: LeBron, Durant, Curry, Harden, Westbrook, Davis, Kawhi; and that's it.
There are at least another 20 stars, considering 24 players are All-Stars each year. Right now it appears Gia and potentially a guy like Kyrie could force their way into the top tier, but most everyone else, for now, is just a star.
A guy like Tatum projects to be a star, although maybe he could become a superstar. Guys like Porzingis, Towns, and Jokic are further along in their progression, but are really in the same boat, just at the front of it. I wouldn't trade Tatum for any of the later guys, I would consider it for Davis though, since he is already a superstar.