Take Jackson.
- high IQ
- great work ethic, reportedly
- smart and emotionally mature (watch his interviews)
- elite athlete
- size and versatility lets him guard 1-3 and play with anyone
- point forward skills, secondary playmaker
- high motor and effort on D, impact player
- rebounds his position (7.4/game)
Fultz doesn't check as many boxes. Fultz can be a tier 1 scorer, but Jackson has Paul Pierce potential.
Didn't we pretty much draft this guy last year?
Nope. They have some things in common though. Jaylen's more of a slasher and a brute force player. Jackson is a more cerebral player on the court (despite Jaylen being some kind of nerd off the court). Jackson is more rangy on D, moves his feet better and threatens to block shots. Higher assist, block, and steal rates... a more impactful defender and a MUCH better passer.
Jackson is a good player, but he played for a better program (and better fit) at an older age.
I may be wrong, but I feel Jaylen has bigger upside.
While I don't necessarily think they would be redundant, and I would have been perfectly happy drafting him at 2/3/4, I don't see how you don't take Fultz at 1.
Jaylen is stronger, a better shooter, and probably better on the low block with his back to the basket. Jaylen is a 3 who plays like a 4. Jackson is a 3 who plays like a 2. I agree, not a lot of overlap.
Let's say both Fultz and Jackson fulfill their potential. Would you rather have the 6'4" scoring machine or the 6'8" 2-way player? Do me a favor and look at the last 30 Finals MVP's.
There was this skinny kid from Philadelphia, about an inch taller than Fultz, who was drafted #13 in 1996. He was a scoring machine. He probably represents Fultz' upside "potential" as a scoring machine.
He's not a popular guy among Celtic fans, but he did have a helluva career.
Fultz actually has a lot of potential on defense as well, by the way. Tremendous wingspan (his dimensions are similar to Wade's). He's a lot younger than Jackson. I don't think it's quite fair to characterize him as just a one-way player yet. Especially if we are talking about 'potential'.