Rudy Gay, Derrick Williams, Michael Beasley, Melo ... these comps don't inspire a lot of confidence.
I'd prefer Fultz, Ball, Jackson, and possibly Monk.
Not quite...but Danny Granger is a good comparison. Both are 6'9 , good scorers
his ACC performance does not impress you?
I think that everyone is forgetting how great of an athlete Granger was without even taking his defense into account, which was also excellent. Tatum isn't even close to that level, imo, not to mention Rudy Gay, who at least entered the league as a very good defensive player, iirc.
Not Channing looks like the classic Duke tweener, to me, like Jabari Parker, who also can't guard anyone. I've also seen Tatum be compared to Tobias Harris, although I feel like Harris is much quicker and a better defender, but that's just off of the top of my head
.