Also let's right some past wrongs here.
Dominique Wilkins, playing 90 games from '97-'99 is eligible! Let's bump T-Mac off the list and put ex-Celtic Dominique Wilkins where he rightfully belongs.
Who was the greater player Wilkins or McGrady?
You take McGrady's best year ('03?), but him on the '88 Hawks over Wilkins, are they taking the C's to 7 games, maybe even beating them? You swap in a prime Wilkins on one of McGrady's first round flameouts ('03, '05, '07, '08), is he taking a team to the 2nd round? Could a 35 year old T-Mac lead the '95 Celtics to 35 wins and the 8th seed! I don't think so. I'd take Wilkins over McGrady.