Although the receivers weren't good this year, we lost in the playoffs because Denver scored every time they had the ball.
Getting Mayo, and Wilfork back will certainly help that but they need to add solid playmakers on the defensive side of the ball, as well as some pass catchers and o lineman.
Assuming the Pats resign Talib, and assuming Wilfork, Kelly, Armstead and Mayo seem to be getting healthy, then the needs are:
TE
S
OLine
in that order.
It would be nice to have Edelman back, but I think it is about 50-50. There aren't that many high quality WRs on the market this year, meaning that teams will overpay at that position.
As a Skins fan looking at the Pats from the outside, I think the Pats biggest problems are
- WR (got to get at least 1 WR that can go long that can stay healthy)
- Defense -- everywhere on D. Pats need players that can stay healthy and have an impact on the game. The team's D when they won the superbowls was loaded with very good defenders that were able to stay on the field (for the most part). As great as Brady was, that D was key to those titles-->if Belicheck had that D the year they were perfect going into the Superbowl they'd have finished perfect (no way Giants are even in position to win it on that wing-and-a-prayer drive) and finally shut that obnoxious bunch of ex-Dolphins up after all these years. (sorry, seen too many stories about them celebrating every time the last undefeated team loses.)
Pats won't win another bowl until they can address those 2 areas.
They are not going to sign a big name WR FA. Why? Too expensive, and too many other areas to address. They will instead count on the development of the rookies, and the improved health of Vereen and Amendola.
"Defense" is sort of a big area, no? I think they will be fine at the DL. They essentially lost 3 starts this year, filled in with undrafted rookies, and still made the AFC championship. They're fine at the DL for now. Mayo will be back and healthy, so they are fine at LB. If they resign Talib, which I think is likely, they are fine at CB. Safety is the biggest area of need on the defense.
Wouldn't hurt for them to add depth to the LB corps. They were fairly inconsistent this year and Spikes won't be coming back.
I don't agree about the LB position. With Collins, Mayo, and Hightower, they're pretty darn good. Then factor in the fact that the Pats play in a sub defense about 2/3 of the time (where one LB comes off the field), and the need for anything more than some FA vet depth at the LB position is pretty small.
I'd rank the Pats needs as follows:
-DT: With Wilfork and Kelly both coming off injuries and both aging, they need a big stopper in the middle to ensure teams can't run on them like they did in the second half (which will help all other areas of the defense, since they won't have to over compensate).
-TE with Gronk up in the air, they really need some more depth here.
-SS: As Rodney Harrison pointed out the other day, there is no enforcer on the defense like when he was here (or Milloy before him). Though I will say that Jamie Collins may be able to somewhat compensate for this with his versatility (even if from the LB spot).
-OG/C: Mankins and Connolly are both getting older and Wendell is a free agent at center. They potentially need a replacement for Wendell (though Connolly has played center for them) and they need depth regardless.
-WR: one could argue this should be a higher priority, but I'd argue they have plenty of decent WR, they just don't have any elite ones. So unless BB plans on trading up to draft a stud or putting together a package for someone like Larry Fitzgerald, I'd rather just sign another vet or two, maybe draft another youngster, and then hope Amendola stays healthy and Dobson emerges as a go to WR (he's shown flashes).
Otherwise, I'm pretty happy with everything else. Ridley/Vereen (and maybe Blount) are a dynamic backfield. Solder/Vollmer are great tackles. Jones and Ninkovich are great ends. And the CB situation is pretty good if Talib returns. Dennard and Ryan are very promising young CBs and while I'm not the biggest Kyle Arrington fan, you could do worse than him as your third or fourth CB.