Some reporters routinely make stuff up. Sherrod is one of them. Sam Smith and Peter Vecsey spread garbage. Gary Washburn doesn't understand the CBA, and his stories (and "sources") often reflect that.
I trust Woj, Stein, Spears, Aldridge, Berger and Lowe. They're not always right, but I don't think they're reporting from the land of make believe. The Herald guys are pretty good, too, on a local level.