Cleveland: I just realized Tony Allen is playing 15 minutes of SF in the playoffs rather than the regular season. Do you feel you're stretching his defensive ability a little too thin by doing that? He has demonstrated to cover SFs in spot situations before, but 15 minutes?! Wouldn't it make sense to play Wallace instead?
As I said in my presser all rotational numbers are an approximation. It will come down to Lionel to decide who to play when. If we're going up against a smaller SF, then maybe Tony gets the nod, because he's still a great finisher at the rim. If it's a bigger guy, then we sacrifice some of our offense in order to contain him by playing Wallace.
On Al Horford and Kevin Garnett,
I would expect most teams to put their center on Horford and keep the big forward on Garnett. I believe Horford's advantage in the low post against PFs will scare more teams than Garnett's will. Given KG's growing disinclination to post up, I think most teams will get away with this strategy.
On defense, I think they will be interchangeable with Horford guarding PFs most often because of his superior quickness + mobility. But if Garnett is facing a center who is wearing him down physically, I think Horford takes over that matchup. I would expect Horford to take the tougher individual matchup more often than Garnett in order to free up KG to roam on defense.
With respect to offense, Horford has been guarded by centers for his entire career and still puts up the numbers he does. If teams do decide to do this, I don't think his numbers will decline. As for KG, he can still shoot over many forwards in this league. That, his PnR game, and his defense, are all we're really asking of him.
I agree with your mentality on defense. Well said. TP.