Post-season wins matter, but when it comes to QBs in Brady/Manning stratosphere, I just can't say who is better. Manning (just one example) would have had a win yesterday if Broncos safety hadn't made an almost unfathomable mistake with 30 seconds left. Brady has a win against Eli without the head-catch or Asante drop (and 2 wins if Wes holds on).
My eyes tell me Brady and Peyton is too close to call, and that both are a notch and a half ahead of Eli.