What Do I Do?

[yngbamm]

I got Romo and Mcnabb at the QB spot Westbrook,gore, and lendale White at RB spot also have Tory Holt,Roy williams and a bunch of other averge WR's....now i been proposed a trade, Westbrook and Mcnabb for Brady and Steve Smith..do i do it? or should i try and get Brady Steve Smith and Jamal Lewis for Romo and Westbrook?

[crownsy]

with smith suspended, i'd get soemthign more back.

westbrook is one of the 4 "elite" backs. you dont trade him unless its for brady and a stud. not brady and a decent WR whos suspended for punching a teammate.

[Big Ticket]

I would do it 1) if you get to start 2 QBs or 2) if you start 1 QB but can find someone to take Romo for a good back....

Actually... who are your other backs?

[Jeff]

I wouldn't do it.  Brady might have a more normal year so Romo could be close to him in production.  Westbrook should have a great year, and the dropoff to a WR (even a good one) is too much to give up.

[yngbamm]

my other backs besides westbrook is gore and lendale white but i would try to trade romo for another back and maybe pick up vince young as a backup qb...so i would start Tom,gore,white,and 3 WR'S so roy,holt,and smith (after suspension) but until then kevin curtis from philly..mean while try to dump romo for a decent RB

[yall hate]

No way.

Romo will likely put up similar numbers to Brady this year.

Westbrook will likely put up significantly more then Smith.

bad trade for you.  It also doesnt seem necessary.  Unless you can get a dominant RB for Romo (which I am not sure, because you wont have a lot of leverage) I just dont see the point

[yngbamm]

what if it was romo/westbrook for brady/smith/lewis?

[crownsy]

what if it was romo/westbrook for brady/smith/lewis?

lewis is half the tail back westbrook is, if that.

i mean, you have one of the top 5 points getters in FF in westbrook, why so eagar to move him?

who are your other backs?

[Roy Hobbs]

who are your other backs?

He mentioned Westbrook, Gore, and Lendale White.

[crownsy]

who are your other backs?

He mentioned Westbrook, Gore, and Lendale White.

that would make me more inclined to hold onto westbrook.

gore is nice, but tends to be middle of the road on points. white is meh.

you can't trade westbrook unless your getting a good back in return + value.

the romo- westbrook trade is ok on brady, but steve smith is suspended for 4 games. lewis is a 3rd down back at the moment, and doesnt hit long homeruns (i.e 70 yard TD screen passes) like westbrook does.

I would not do that trade.

[yngbamm]

thanks for the advice everyone! i guess i was just hoping i could find another reason to cheer for Brady 

[yall hate]

who are your other backs?

He mentioned Westbrook, Gore, and Lendale White.

that would make me more inclined to hold onto westbrook.

gore is nice, but tends to be middle of the road on points. white is meh.

you can't trade westbrook unless your getting a good back in return + value.

the romo- westbrook trade is ok on brady, but steve smith is suspended for 4 games. lewis is a 3rd down back at the moment, and doesnt hit long homeruns (i.e 70 yard TD screen passes) like westbrook does.

I would not do that trade.

Smith is only suspended for 2 games.

And Lewis is their starting RB.  I dont want him on my fantasy team, but he did rush for 1300 yards, 9 tds, with 250 more yards recieving and 2 tds last year.  He had a much better season last year then his last couple...

[crownsy]

who are your other backs?

He mentioned Westbrook, Gore, and Lendale White.

that would make me more inclined to hold onto westbrook.

gore is nice, but tends to be middle of the road on points. white is meh.

you can't trade westbrook unless your getting a good back in return + value.

the romo- westbrook trade is ok on brady, but steve smith is suspended for 4 games. lewis is a 3rd down back at the moment, and doesnt hit long homeruns (i.e 70 yard TD screen passes) like westbrook does.

I would not do that trade.

Smith is only suspended for 2 games.

And Lewis is their starting RB.  I dont want him on my fantasy team, but he did rush for 1300 yards, 9 tds, with 250 more yards recieving and 2 tds last year.  He had a much better season last year then his last couple...

ok, my fault its 2 games. but what, exactly are you upgrading with this trade?

you are losing the NFL's leading rusher and yards from scrimmage back. a number one option in his offense.

You are upgrading at QB, certainly, but its not like romo is trash.

and in return you get a WR (who are hit and miss in fantasy, not worth half of what a RB is.) who will only play 14 games at best.

you get a RB who had one decent year after two horrid ones, and doesnt get as many carries.

so your essential giving this guy one of the elite backs, taking back a meh one, and slightly upgrading your QB. why would you do this?

westbrook should not be part of any deal you make. he's to valuable. he's far more valuable than anything your getting back in either of those trades.

if you could do it for gore, mabey, white, defintly.

westbrook? no way.

[yall hate]

who are your other backs?

He mentioned Westbrook, Gore, and Lendale White.

that would make me more inclined to hold onto westbrook.

gore is nice, but tends to be middle of the road on points. white is meh.

you can't trade westbrook unless your getting a good back in return + value.

the romo- westbrook trade is ok on brady, but steve smith is suspended for 4 games. lewis is a 3rd down back at the moment, and doesnt hit long homeruns (i.e 70 yard TD screen passes) like westbrook does.

I would not do that trade.

Smith is only suspended for 2 games.

And Lewis is their starting RB.  I dont want him on my fantasy team, but he did rush for 1300 yards, 9 tds, with 250 more yards recieving and 2 tds last year.  He had a much better season last year then his last couple...

ok, my fault its 2 games. but what, exactly are you upgrading with this trade?

you are losing the NFL's leading rusher and yards from scrimmage back. a number one option in his offense.

You are upgrading at QB, certainly, but its not like romo is trash.

and in return you get a WR (who are hit and miss in fantasy, not worth half of what a RB is.) who will only play 14 games at best.

you get a RB who had one decent year after two horrid ones, and doesnt get as many carries.

so your essential giving this guy one of the elite backs, taking back a meh one, and slightly upgrading your QB. why would you do this?

westbrook should not be part of any deal you make. he's to valuable. he's far more valuable than anything your getting back in either of those trades.

if you could do it for gore, mabey, white, defintly.


westbrook? no way.

I agree with you.  If you go back up and read the thread, I said no way I would do it.

Just pointing out the error.