...
For the record, I've watched Randoph in the Summer League and I'm not impressed. I wouldn't be surprised to see him joining Hendrix in Nellie's doghouse, with Belinelli getting minutes at the wings behind Jax-Maggette-Azubuike.
I caught one of GS's summer league games. I only had it on because it was against Dallas, and I wanted to see what Gerald was looking like. Maybe if was just that one game, but Randolph looked very talented in that game. Looked like he had a natural feel for the game, unlike poor Gerald (great athlete; no feel for the game).
I also saw that game. No argument about his raw talent. He has tons of potential. But with the potential comes a huge risk as well. I don't know how to project his career. He may be a new Odom, a very skilled and atypical left-handed player. Or a major bust, I don't know.
But, currently, I fail to see how can he be useful on a NBA court. He plays like a face up 4, but he's too thin to play inside. And he won't be able to play from the perimeter, because his long-range shots are not very good, to say the least. His shooting motion is too slow and his mechanics need work. He has a great first step, but NBA defenders are too quick, athletic and smart: they'll cheat on him, giving him a couple of feet until he gets a shot good enough to punish them. I think he may struggle against more structured defences.
The single aspect of his game that makes me more suspicious is his defence. Who's he going to guard? Easy to post up, troubles fighting screens, moves his hands too much.
Yeah, he's a far better player than Green, with the natural feel for the game that good ol'Gerald misses. No doubt about that. Still, I think there's something that bond them: they both are the kind of players who were always the best in their teams, in the playground, in the high-school, especially because of their athleticism and ability to put the ball in the basket. So, they never learned the fundamentals of the game, relying heavily (and way too much for my taste) in their natural talents.
That's why I think there's a good chance of Randolph not getting many minutes until he develops some parts of his game and gains bulk.