I agree Artest is, talent-wise, a upgrade over Odom is most aspects. Artest can really play the game. That said, I would not trade a used bag of balls for him. Too much baggage, too many potential problems. Look at it this way - think of the most notorious problam guys in terms of character (particularly off the court) in the last decade or so: Spree, Artest, Barkley (maybe), Jackson, Telfair (maybe), Iverson (maybe), Kemp, Baker, Randolf, Bozi Wells, etc. (these are off the top of my head, and the "maybes" depend on one's own perspective). What have they won? Nothing. I think there is a reason for that.
One response is that 'Sheed won, and maybe that is valid, but he really celaned up his off-the-court stuff by the time he won. Perhaps it doesn't make a difference, but I see that over and over again, the cohesive teams with few off-the-court character issues are the winners. Doesn't there have to be something to that?
This is one of the best examples of cherry picking I've ever scene.
1. Barkley, Kemp, Iverson, and I think Spree all went to the finals at some point in their careers, they just happened to face dynasties in the 2000 era LAL and 90s era Bulls. You could say the same thing for alleged do gooders Stockton and Malone.
2. Sheed did win - can't discount it.
3. How do you make a list of head cases and leave off the indisputed leader: Dennis Rodman, he only has 5 more rings than most people.
4. I believe Jackson won a ring with SA early in his career (Stephen Jackson right?)
5. Telfair? How does he even fit here - I think his problem is talent not attitude, but even still he's been in the league four year.
I think Artest is a fine move. Don't let the stupidity of signing look Walton prevent you from making the right move. Just tell Luke, you are going to bench him indefinitely, and then offer a buyout. LAL can afford it, and I don't think they'll be under the cap soon making moves. They will need a backup big man still - but who doesn't - and they'll still have the full MLE to use to get it. The traingle is built upon ball movement leading to isolation play, which is what Artest does. He'll be functional passing - not a creator, but that's all they'd need.
Farmar / Fisher
Kobe / Sasha
Artest / Vlad
Gasol / Walton
Bynum / Mihm
Certainly its a team that has room for improvement, really at the guard spot and backup C/PF spot. Sounds familar. If they weren't p[aying JAckson a billion dollars and it being such a risk to bring in a new coach to deal with Kobe - then Jackson could be improved at this point, he seems disinterested at best.