I think Toronto wins in this one, any deal where one superduper (when healthy, admittedly) goes for 2 or 3 fairly average guys, the team that sends the 2 or 3 tends to win - look at Boston with Ray Ray and KG, look at NJ with Vince (who did Toronto get anyway?) Look at Miami with Shaq (they got a title out of it) - Toronto wins this one, the talent will find its way to play together...
O'Neal
Bosh
Moon
Parker
Calderon
That's a nice looking 5, add in Bargani, and a FA or two, and that's a top 5 team in the east