CelticsStrong

Around the League => Transaction Ideas and Rumors => Topic started by: csfansince60s on November 24, 2012, 10:33:19 AM

Title: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: csfansince60s on November 24, 2012, 10:33:19 AM
Firstly, Phoenix, which could be done on Dec. 15th:

Sarver is one cheap owner, and the Suns are looking to the future, as the present is somewhat bleak.

Sarver will want two of Bradley/Sully/Melo, as they are all cheap (on rookie deals) and will probably want an expiring and picks.

Since this has to be done sooner, rather than later, Courtney Lee will be the sacrificial lamb as his contract is the first of Green/Bass/Lee that can be traded.

Lee's 4 year $5mil may be palatable to Sarver, but I can see him demanding a third team be involved to get him an expiring.

Also, everyone assumes that it is Bradley who will be demanded by Sarver. I'm not so sure that Bradley's trade value due to the question marks about his health is as high around the league as it is on this blog.

I can see Sarver taking Sully/Melo plus Lee/expiring from 3rd team and picks.

Now Atlanta:

Aside from Josh Smith and Horford, Atlanta is pretty weak as far as starting "talent" goes, especially at the 3/4. Enter Jeff Green and Brandon Bass. Both have been starters for talented teams and both are definitely an upgrade over what Atlanta has (or doesn't have) right now, aside from Josh Smith.

Smith will most likely be leaving at year's end, and they could lose him for nothing.

If Atlanta is building around Horford, they need to surround him with some talent. Both Green and Bass are close to Horford's age and fill a need. So:

On January 15th, Green and Bass for Josh Smith.

Add Kmart and Pietrus, and we are good to go.

Gortat/Wilcox/Collins
KG/JSmith/Kmart
Paul Pierce/Pietrus/Joseph
Bradley/Jet
Rondo/Barbosa

Title: Re: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: OttawaCeltic on November 24, 2012, 10:35:37 AM
Firstly, Phoenix, which could be done on Dec. 15th:

Sarver is one cheap owner, and the Suns are looking to the future, as the present is somewhat bleak.

Sarver will want two of Bradley/Sully/Melo, as they are all cheap (on rookie deals) and will probably want an expiring and picks.

Since this has to be done sooner, rather than later, Courtney Lee will be the sacrificial lamb as his contract is the first of Green/Bass/Lee that can be traded.

Lee's 4 year $5mil may be palatable to Sarver, but I can see him demanding a third team be involved to get him an expiring.

Also, everyone assumes that it is Bradley who will be demanded by Sarver. I'm not so sure that Bradley's trade value due to the question marks about his health is as high around the league as it is on this blog.

I can see Sarver taking Sully/Melo plus Lee/expiring from 3rd team and picks.

Now Atlanta:

Aside from Josh Smith and Horford, Atlanta is pretty weak as far as starting "talent" goes, especially at the 3/4. Enter Jeff Green and Brandon Bass. Both have been starters for talented teams and both are definitely an upgrade over what Atlanta has (or doesn't have) right now, aside from Josh Smith.

Smith will most likely be leaving at year's end, and they could lose him for nothing.

If Atlanta is building around Horford, they need to surround him with some talent. Both Green and Bass are close to Horford's age and fill a need. So:

On January 15th, Green and Bass for Josh Smith.

Add Kmart and Pietrus, and we are good to go.

Gortat/Wilcox/Collins
KG/JSmith/Kmart
Paul Pierce/Pietrus/Joseph
Bradley/Jet
Rondo/Barbosa

I don't know about u, but I LOVE that line-up but J.Smith would HATE it. He would wanna be beside Rondo in the rotations, not behind  ::)

But I think Gortat can come off the bench like in Orlando:
KG/Gortat/Collins
JSmith/Wilcox
Paul Pierce/Pietrus/Joseph
Bradley/Jet
Rondo/Barbosa
Title: Re: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: csfansince60s on November 24, 2012, 10:47:53 AM
Firstly, Phoenix, which could be done on Dec. 15th:

Sarver is one cheap owner, and the Suns are looking to the future, as the present is somewhat bleak.

Sarver will want two of Bradley/Sully/Melo, as they are all cheap (on rookie deals) and will probably want an expiring and picks.

Since this has to be done sooner, rather than later, Courtney Lee will be the sacrificial lamb as his contract is the first of Green/Bass/Lee that can be traded.

Lee's 4 year $5mil may be palatable to Sarver, but I can see him demanding a third team be involved to get him an expiring.

Also, everyone assumes that it is Bradley who will be demanded by Sarver. I'm not so sure that Bradley's trade value due to the question marks about his health is as high around the league as it is on this blog.

I can see Sarver taking Sully/Melo plus Lee/expiring from 3rd team and picks.

Now Atlanta:

Aside from Josh Smith and Horford, Atlanta is pretty weak as far as starting "talent" goes, especially at the 3/4. Enter Jeff Green and Brandon Bass. Both have been starters for talented teams and both are definitely an upgrade over what Atlanta has (or doesn't have) right now, aside from Josh Smith.

Smith will most likely be leaving at year's end, and they could lose him for nothing.

If Atlanta is building around Horford, they need to surround him with some talent. Both Green and Bass are close to Horford's age and fill a need. So:

On January 15th, Green and Bass for Josh Smith.

Add Kmart and Pietrus, and we are good to go.

Gortat/Wilcox/Collins
KG/JSmith/Kmart
Paul Pierce/Pietrus/Joseph
Bradley/Jet
Rondo/Barbosa

I don't know about u, but I LOVE that line-up but J.Smith would HATE it. He would wanna be beside Rondo in the rotations, not behind  ::)

But I think Gortat can come off the bench like in Orlando:
KG/Gortat/Collins
JSmith/Wilcox
Paul Pierce/Pietrus/Joseph
Bradley/Jet
Rondo/Barbosa

Excellent point...I'm sold.  :) The only question is "Will Phoenix and Atlanta be?"
Title: Re: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: Moranis on November 24, 2012, 11:25:13 AM
There is no way Boston is getting both Josh Smith and Marcin Gortat unless Rajon Rondo is traded.  Period.
Title: Re: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: celticslove on November 24, 2012, 12:34:30 PM
There is no way Boston is getting both Josh Smith and Marcin Gortat unless Rajon Rondo is traded.  Period.
this. pierce or rondo will be included if we get them both.
Title: Re: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: Yoki_IsTheName on November 24, 2012, 12:41:30 PM
Gortat and Smoove for our good but ARE role players? Man is do that in a heartbeat.

Unfortunately though, ATL and PHX would never do that. That's just so one sided for us. And one sided trades normally don't work in real life.
Title: Re: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: Kane3387 on November 24, 2012, 12:43:02 PM
Gortat and bass to Atlanta

Smith to Boston

Lee, zaza, Jenkins,  melo and picks to  suns
Title: Re: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: csfansince60s on November 24, 2012, 12:51:42 PM
There is no way Boston is getting both Josh Smith and Marcin Gortat unless Rajon Rondo is traded.  Period.
this. pierce or rondo will be included if we get them both.

Rondo, I can understand, but not Pierce.

Sarver (being as cheap as he is) wouldn't want Pierce based on his contract alone, nevermind that he wouldn't fit into the Sun's immediate plans.

Hawks wouldn't want Pierce, because of his age.
Title: Re: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: Evantime34 on November 24, 2012, 12:59:10 PM
Gortat and bass to Atlanta

Smith to Boston

Lee, zaza, Jenkins,  melo and picks to  suns
The question would be how many picks. I think the Suns would want two with that package. That or one and Sullinger instead of Melo (which I would do).
Title: Re: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: eugen on November 24, 2012, 11:32:03 PM
Nobody will come. ::)
Title: Re: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: Who on November 25, 2012, 06:15:48 AM
Nobody will come. ::)
Agreed - I don't think we have the assets to get either player.
Title: Re: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: mrpoundforpound on November 25, 2012, 12:49:37 PM
It's fine i think Jeff Green will be better than both of these. we have a bright future with JG
Title: Re: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: pearljammer10 on November 25, 2012, 01:21:46 PM
Im not a fan of Josh Smith coming off the bench on that team. He would need to be starting.
Title: Re: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: csfansince60s on November 25, 2012, 03:48:54 PM
Im not a fan of Josh Smith coming off the bench on that team. He would need to be starting.

Agreed...and with Gortat and Wilcox/Kmart and Jet coming off the bench, that's an impressive rotation.
Title: Re: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: pearljammer10 on November 25, 2012, 04:01:56 PM
Im not a fan of Josh Smith coming off the bench on that team. He would need to be starting.

Agreed...and with Gortat and Wilcox/Kmart and Jet coming off the bench, that's an impressive rotation.

Impressive indeed.

Rondo/Barbosa
Bradley/JET
Pierce/Green
Smith/Wilcox
KG/Gortat

That is a lineup I could more then live with. Especially then bench. With Gorata Terry and Green all getting 20 - 25 minutes and wilcox and barbosa filling in for some sparks. Thats deadly.
Title: Re: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: Edgar on November 25, 2012, 11:47:35 PM
Im not a fan of Josh Smith coming off the bench on that team. He would need to be starting.

Agreed...and with Gortat and Wilcox/Kmart and Jet coming off the bench, that's an impressive rotation.

Impressive indeed.

Rondo/Barbosa
Bradley/JET
Pierce/Green
Smith/Wilcox
KG/Gortat

That is a lineup I could more then live with. Especially then bench. With Gorata Terry and Green all getting 20 - 25 minutes and wilcox and barbosa filling in for some sparks. Thats deadly.

Rajon Rondo ,  Sam Cassell
Ray Alllen    Eddie House
Paul Pierce     Allen, Tony
Kevin Garnett   Leon Powe
KendrickPerkins  PJ Brown (aka the X factor)


To be honest the bench is better, but the................... desire is waaaaay less
Title: Re: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: mrpoundforpound on November 25, 2012, 11:57:20 PM
Im not a fan of Josh Smith coming off the bench on that team. He would need to be starting.

Agreed...and with Gortat and Wilcox/Kmart and Jet coming off the bench, that's an impressive rotation.

Impressive indeed.

Rondo/Barbosa
Bradley/JET
Pierce/Green
Smith/Wilcox
KG/Gortat

That is a lineup I could more then live with. Especially then bench. With Gorata Terry and Green all getting 20 - 25 minutes and wilcox and barbosa filling in for some sparks. Thats deadly.

Rajon Rondo ,  Sam Cassell
Ray Alllen    Eddie House
Paul Pierce     Allen, Tony
Kevin Garnett   Leon Powe
KendrickPerkins  PJ Brown (aka the X factor)


To be honest the bench is better, but the................... desire is waaaaay less

the bench is much better now. green and barbosa could score more than the entire old bench on any night
Title: Re: Gortat?/Josh Smith?...why not both?
Post by: wdleehi on November 26, 2012, 07:11:41 AM
Im not a fan of Josh Smith coming off the bench on that team. He would need to be starting.

Agreed...and with Gortat and Wilcox/Kmart and Jet coming off the bench, that's an impressive rotation.

Impressive indeed.

Rondo/Barbosa
Bradley/JET
Pierce/Green
Smith/Wilcox
KG/Gortat

That is a lineup I could more then live with. Especially then bench. With Gorata Terry and Green all getting 20 - 25 minutes and wilcox and barbosa filling in for some sparks. Thats deadly.

Rajon Rondo ,  Sam Cassell
Ray Alllen    Eddie House
Paul Pierce     Allen, Tony
Kevin Garnett   Leon Powe
KendrickPerkins  PJ Brown (aka the X factor)


To be honest the bench is better, but the................... desire is waaaaay less

the bench is much better now. green and barbosa could score more than the entire old bench on any night


Just like the Laker's bench that season.  All we hear going into the Finals was how the Lakers bench was so much better. 


The Celtics bench outplayed them.


The 08 bench was good.  It's strengths complimented the starters.  They had players with specific roles and they filled those roles. 


The 08 bench was better then the current bench.